Arizona Certification Toolkit
- July 30, 2024
Election certification is mandatory, on purpose
- Arizona state law says certification is a mandatory, ministerial duty – meaning that officials have no discretion to refuse to certify election results.
- It’s not an accident that certification is mandatory. It’s in direct response to past partisan attempts to sabotage certification to change election outcomes – attempts which both lawmakers and the courts recognized as a threat to democracy.
- Officials who have refused to complete certification of an election – or threatened to do so – fundamentally misunderstand or willfully disregard both their legal obligations and the actual purpose of certification.
Opportunities to address alleged fraud or errors exist outside the certification process
- The post-election process leading up to the final canvass includes many steps to ensure that only valid, legal ballots are counted.
- There are legitimate ways to address potential fraud or error. Delaying the canvass is not one of them.
- There are other processes to contest results or administration of an election, including recounts and election contests.
There are two principal ways to address concerns about election fraud or irregularities: election contests and recounts. These can take place only after the county canvass is complete.
Officials may face legal consequences if they refuse to certify
- Any attempt to interfere with the certification process should be met with an immediate response, as failure to certify is illegal and disruptive.
- Arizona law and federal law have many safeguards in place to ensure that certification happens, including civil accountability and criminal penalties.
- Two Cochise County supervisors who refused to certify the 2022 election have been criminally prosecuted for interfering with the election process.
Additional Resources
Election Certification
Cochise County
- Mandamus petitions filed by Arizona Secretary of State and Arizona voters
- Indictment charging Peggy Judd and Tom Crosby
- June 2024 denial of motion to remand the case to the grand jury
- Criminal docket
Related Content
It can happen here.
We can stop it.
Defeating authoritarianism is going to take all of us. Everyone and every institution has a role to play. Together, we can protect democracy.
DonateSign Up for Updates Sign Up for Updates
Explore Careers Explore Careers
How to Protect Democracy How to Protect Democracy